Watford’s Carabao Cup Conundrum: Did Referee Get it Right?
In a thrilling Carabao Cup clash between Watford and Manchester City, the Hornets’ fans were left fuming after a potential equalizing goal was disallowed. And now, the team has taken to TikTok to air their grievances, posting a side-by-side comparison with a similar incident involving Erling Haaland. So, did referee David Webb make the right call?
The controversy surrounded Kwadwo Baah’s effort, which was ruled out for a perceived foul on City’s young debutant Kaden Braithwaite. But, as the footage shows, the contact between the two players was minimal, and many would argue that it was a fair challenge. Baah’s strength and explosive pace allowed him to win the ball, but Webb deemed it a penalty and awarded City a free kick.
Watford boss Tom Cleverley was understandably frustrated with the decision, telling the Watford Observer: "For me, that’s a perfectly good goal. Baah is a strong and explosive player against a young lad, and it can maybe look over aggressive, but it’s actually shoulder to shoulder. It’s disappointing, but after the controversy at the weekend, you don’t expect to get those ones."
The question on everyone’s mind is: would the decision have been different if the incident had occurred at the other end of the pitch? Cleverley remained tight-lipped on the matter, simply stating that he thought the goal should have stood. With Watford crashing out of the competition, this could have been a pivotal moment in the game.
In the end, City went on to win 2-1, but Watford’s efforts will be remembered for their bravery in speaking out against what they believe was an unfair decision. The video has already racked up over two million views on TikTok, with the caption reading: "Make that 116 charges" – a cheeky reference to the ongoing hearing into City’s alleged breaches of financial rules.
So, what do you think? Did referee Webb get it right? Let us know in the comments! And, if you want to stay up-to-date with all the latest news and opinions, be sure to follow us on all social media platforms for more updates!