The Magpies’ Dream XI That Never Was: A Blast from the Past
Three years have passed since Newcastle United’s takeover by the Saudi Arabian-led consortium, and what a wild ride it has been. Fans and pundits alike have debated the prospects of the team, predicting who would make the squad. One such XI made headlines, compiled by BBC Sport, which featured a mix of players rumored to be on the club’s radar. Looking back, this team was… less than impressive.
The XI That Could Have Been
Goalkeeper: Karl Darlow
In 2021, Darlow was a viable option for the Magpies, but by the time the takeover occurred, he had already lost his place to Martin Dúbravka.
Defenders:
- James Tarkowski: Linked to Newcastle in the early days, Tarkowski has since joined Everton.
- Eric Bailly: Despite his talent, injuries and loan spells have stunted his development.
- Federico Fernandez: The Argentine defender currently plies his trade with Elche.
- Aaron Ramsey: Linked to a return to the Premier League, Ramsey joined Rangers on loan and then signed for Nice, later moving to Cardiff City on a free transfer.
- Donny van de Beek: Initially hyped for his transfer to Manchester United, he’s since struggled to establish himself.
Forwards:
- Jesse Lingard: Failed to impress on loan at West Ham, Lingard eventually left Manchester United for Nottingham Forest, before moving to South Korean side FC Seoul.
- Anthony Martial: Released by United, Martial currently plays for AEK Athens.
- Mauro Icardi: Linked to numerous Premier League clubs, Icardi has continued to score for Galatasaray, without ever making the switch.
Analysis
The inclusion of Karl Darlow in goal raised eyebrows, as he was already a fringe player by the time of the takeover. Tarkowski’s arrival in the Premier League was not accompanied by a significant upturn in his form, while Bailly’s fitness issues have hampered his career. Fernandez, like Darlow, was struggling for game time, while Ramsey’s inconsistent form at Newcastle led to his exit. Van de Beek, touted as a talented signing, failed to establish himself at Manchester United. The forwards were no exception, with Lingard failing to replicate his West Ham form, Martial struggling with injuries, and Icardi never materializing into the Premier League player expected of him.
Lessons Learned
This exercise in hindsight highlights the complexities of building a successful squad. While individual players can shine, a cohesive team effort is paramount. It also underscores the importance of thorough scouting, careful budget management, and effective management of player development.
Conclusion
This XI represents a missed opportunity for the Magpies. As Newcastle looks to build a formidable squad, we can reflect on the what-ifs of the past. Fans can only hope that future transfers will be more prudent and successful.
Stay Informed
Follow us on all social media platforms for more updates on the Premier League and Newcastle United!